The news of China Gorman’s departure from SHRM cast a bit of a pall on the HREvolution 2010 event a couple of weeks ago.
Someone said they felt hopeless. I myself felt discouraged and let down. I don’t really care much about social media, except as a way to connect with people who practice the kind of progressive, candid, risk-friendly HR I wasn’t seeing at SHRM events. Speaking plainly, I think local SHRM chapters are often cliquish, conservative, behind the times, useless to those with more than five years of experience, and a little greedy. I think they get the tacit nod toward these behaviors from SHRM National. When China, who went from SHRM COO to interim CEO to Global Outreach Something Or Another, chose to resign, I took it as a sign that SHRM would never “get it,” and my last hopes regarding the organization’s direction went up in smoke. I felt that momentum that had been building towards change in SHRM had taken a big step backward.
I was wrong. Not necessarily about SHRM, but about the pedestal I put China on. It’s a little like the difference between the Obama campaign and his administration. We’re learning in lots of different ways that no one person can make things much better on their own. Barack Obama, China Gorman, our CEOs, all need US to create and sustain momentum and leadership. They can’t do it alone. Asking them to do so and then being disappointed when they can’t deliver is a complete cop-out, and creates a dangerous level of apathy. I think people want to be lead. But we decline responsibility for our own role as leaders at the expense of our families, neighborhoods, workplaces, associations and even country. We have to do the work ourselves.
My friend Victorio Milian asked his readers to put up or shut up, to help create bright spots of positive change within our own spheres of influence. So, Victorio, here’s what I’m doing about it.
- I’m developing and leading a class on creating efficiencies in a one-person HR shop. The workshop will be held at HRFlorida 2010 and, afterward, I’ll post a series of articles on the subject. (This has recently been approved for three HRCI strategic recertification hours, so come on along!)
- I’m using four vacation days to present at and blog about HRFlorida.
- I’m using another three vacation days to blog about HRSouthwest.
- I contacted HRHouston about helping them get their 2011 Gulf Coast Symposium plugged in to the online world. (I’ve got to comment here – the first thing they wanted me to do was join for $275 to get the pleasure of helping them. I can’t say I’m excited about this particular opportunity.)
- At each regional or local SHRM chapter that I touch, I’m going to host open hours for anyone who wants to learn more about how to connect with the smart and business-savvy HR community that populates twitter, the blogging world, ERE, and the like. I don’t think that everyone has to blog and tweet and involve themselves with social media, but all HR pros need to know how to readily source interesting business ideas and next-level HR thinking.
- I think I’m not going to rejoin SHRM National this year. I don’t really think it matters to them, but I just can’t believe that it’s worth any more investment. I’ve paid into SHRM National for ten years. That’s enough.
China, I’m going to miss you at SHRM National, no way around it. But I do apologize for turning you into a two-dimensional Joan of Arc character, and for not stepping up to the plate earlier. I’ll help create bright spots within local SHRM chapters and within the HR field. Thank you for your perseverance and your leadership. And thanks for helping remind us that we’re all capable of leading, if we choose to take it on.








#1 by @ChinaGorman on May 26, 2010 - 8:00 am
Quote
Franny: See? My work here is done!
But really, thanks for the kind words — and the commitment to creating bright spots of positive change particularly in relation to SHRM local chapters. And make no mistake, SHRM cares if you don’t renew. We care when any member doesn’t renew. But we really care when a smart, activist HR pro doesn’t renew.
I’ll see you at HRFlorida! Thanks again for your personal engagement with me over the last year or so. I really learned a lot from you.
#2 by Joan Ginsberg on May 26, 2010 - 8:42 am
Quote
Geez, I am SO glad you are on vacation – you have written some great posts lately! This one is my favorite, because you are talking about the DO, not the should do.
I have a list of similar outreach projects for my own SHRM local, for the same reasons. But I haven’t translated them into a concrete form, yet. I am at the should do stage.
You have made me decide to get off my butt and start making those plans. You rock, girl!
#3 by Kimberly Roden on May 26, 2010 - 9:39 am
Quote
I love this post, Franny! I’m glad it’s not just me having less than watered-down experiences at local SHRM meetings.
More importantly… look at you go! Really impressive plan to take your ideas to the next level. All HR professionals should be focused on next-level thinking, remaining connected and staying current. I’m really looking forward to watching your plan unfold!
#4 by Lori Goldsmith on May 26, 2010 - 4:25 pm
Quote
First of all, I’m just so excited you will be presenting at our HR Florida conference creating bright spots for the 1 person+ HR department.
What an eye opener. We all must make sure we are creating bright spots in our local chapters and for SHRM as well. China, we are going to miss you, our job is to forge ahead and carry the torch forward to the next level through the path you created…and Franny, great job for starting the “DO”!
#5 by Michael VanDervort on May 26, 2010 - 6:55 pm
Quote
We should all steal this idea!
At each regional or local SHRM chapter that I touch, I’m going to host open hours for anyone who wants to learn more about how to connect with the smart and business-savvy HR community that populates twitter, the blogging world, ERE, and the like. I don’t think that everyone has to blog and tweet and involve themselves with social media, but all HR pros need to know how to readily source interesting business ideas and next-level HR thinking.
#6 by Lisa Rosendahl on May 26, 2010 - 6:58 pm
Quote
I love this post Franny and through your eyes, I see action. Thanks for the inspiration.
#7 by Frannyo on May 26, 2010 - 8:53 pm
Quote
You know, I’m being unfair about local SHRM chapters, particularly the “cliquish” part. I just walk in feeling like I don’t fit in, partly because I don’t dress in suits and partly because I’ve only met one person at a local SHRM meeting who I really got excited about talking with more. (Bambi McCullough from Sterling Bank and then Chrysalis Consulting, I’m looking at you!) So I may put out a vibe that doesn’t give people much opportunity to feel comfortable around me, and I translate that as cliquish. I’m going to see if I can change that up a bit.
#8 by Teresa Morris on May 26, 2010 - 10:04 pm
Quote
I love reading that the fire you had at HRevolution is still burning strongly, and I’m loving your action plan even more.
This is inspiring me to figure out how to do something similar (with less public speaking – I’m not ready for that!) as it relates to finding my small business finance/accounting community.
Isn’t that really what we’re all trying to do? Find our community and reach out to them to find ways to better ourselves?
Keep it up, Franny – you know we’ve got your back.
#9 by Krista Francis on May 27, 2010 - 11:50 am
Quote
Thanks for your put up or shut up post, Franny! SHRM is an easy target for ribbing or outright bashing. It’s much harder to actually do something about it and ‘become the change’ you’d like to see.
#10 by Chris Havrilla on May 28, 2010 - 7:30 am
Quote
Great post, Franny! You really are an inspiration — not only inspiring to action, but inspiring to keeping open minds and never stopping to look at things in new and different ways.
ch:)
Pingback: The Fine Line Between Cliques and Teams — hr bartender
Pingback: The Fine Line Between Cliques and Teams | HRM Today